Key takeaways
- A non-reactive pot: Stainless steel is the usual choice. Aluminum and unlined cast iron can react with acid.
- A reliable thermometer: Temperature control decides whether the curd sets. If the kit does not include one, buy a digital probe thermometer.
- A long knife and slotted spoon: For cutting and lifting curd.
- A colander and cloth: Most kits supply butter muslin or cheesecloth, though a second piece is handy.
- A microwave-safe bowl: For stretching mozzarella curd in hot water or in the microwave.
- Food-safe gloves: Stretching hot curd is easier and safer with them.
For a first cheese, the New England Cheesemaking Supply Mozzarella and Ricotta kit suits the most beginners, Urban Cheesecraft suits anyone who wants a low-commitment trial or a gift, and Standing Stone Farms or The Big Cheese suit people who want more variety from a single box. Those who want to move on to cheddar, Gouda or other aged cheeses need cultures, a mold and a press, which most beginner kits do not include. This guide sets out what each kit contains, what you still need to supply, and which buyer each one fits.
Our top picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
At a Glance: Cheese Making Kits Compared
| Kit | Cheeses | Batches / yield | Included | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New England Cheesemaking Supply Mozzarella and Ricotta | Mozzarella, ricotta | Up to 20 one-pound batches | Citric acid, cheese salt, vegetable rennet tablets, butter muslin, thermometer | Two cheeses only; no cultures for aged styles |
| Urban Cheesecraft Mozzarella, Ricotta and Farmers’ Cheese | Three fresh cheeses | Four batches of roughly one to one-and-a-half pounds | Metal probe thermometer, cheesecloth, vegetarian rennet, citric acid, flake salt | Only four batches |
| Standing Stone Farms Ultimate | 14 or more, including mozzarella, feta, halloumi, cheddar curds | Roughly 20 to 25 gallons of milk | Mesophilic and thermophilic cultures, liquid rennet, calcium chloride, citric acid, salt, drain cloth | No thermometer, mold or press |
| The Big Cheese Ultimate | Ten fresh styles such as mozzarella, ricotta, mascarpone, halloumi, paneer, labneh | 40 batches | Vegetarian rennet, citric acid, sea salt, spices, molds, thermometer, butter muslin | No bacterial cultures, so no aged cheeses |
| Fermentaholics DIY Fresh Cheese | Seven, including ricotta, burrata, paneer, cottage cheese | Not stated | Microbial rennet tablets, cheese salt, citric acid, cheesecloth | No thermometer; no cultures for aged cheeses |
The contents above follow the Thomas Acres roundup, supported by other outlets that list the New England Cheesemaking Supply kit as the beginner favorite. Reviewers disagree on whether that kit includes a thermometer, with some listing one and one saying you will need your own, so a reader who needs one should confirm what is in the box they receive. Several roundups in circulation are affiliate-style, so treat ranking claims with caution.
Fresh Cheese Kits Versus Aged Cheese Kits
Almost every beginner kit makes fresh cheese: mozzarella, ricotta, paneer, halloumi, mascarpone. These are acid or rennet set, drained, and eaten within days. They need little equipment and give results in an afternoon. Aged cheeses such as cheddar, Colby, feta in brine or Gouda are a different project. They use bacterial cultures, a mold to shape the curd, a press to apply pressure, and weeks or months of controlled aging. A kit that lists cultures and calcium chloride, such as Standing Stone Farms Ultimate, points toward that second path, but the same roundup notes it contains no mold or press, so hard cheeses require extra gear.
The practical advice is to start with fresh cheese, make a few batches, and decide whether the hobby sticks before buying a press. Plenty of home cheese makers stay with fresh styles for good.
Milk Matters More Than the Kit
Every source stresses the same constraint: ultra-pasteurized milk will not set properly. Most supermarket shelves stock it, so read the label. Use regular pasteurized milk, or raw milk where it is legal and you have confidence in the source. Homogenized milk works for most fresh cheeses, though non-homogenized milk gives a firmer curd for some. Goat and sheep milk can be used with kits designed for them, such as Fermentaholics according to the Thomas Acres review, but results differ from cow milk and recipes may need small changes.
Expect to buy a gallon or two of milk for each batch, so the cost of a kit is partly the cost of milk. A kit that lists 40 batches only delivers that count if you keep buying milk in quantity.
What Else You Need
- A non-reactive pot: Stainless steel is the usual choice. Aluminum and unlined cast iron can react with acid.
- A reliable thermometer: Temperature control decides whether the curd sets. If the kit does not include one, buy a digital probe thermometer.
- A long knife and slotted spoon: For cutting and lifting curd.
- A colander and cloth: Most kits supply butter muslin or cheesecloth, though a second piece is handy.
- A microwave-safe bowl: For stretching mozzarella curd in hot water or in the microwave.
- Food-safe gloves: Stretching hot curd is easier and safer with them.
Sanitation matters. Wash and rinse every tool in hot water, and avoid strong-scented detergents that can leave residue. Fresh cheeses are perishable; store them in the refrigerator and follow the kit’s guidance on how long they keep. People who are pregnant, immunocompromised or elderly should check food-safety guidance from a doctor or a public health agency before eating homemade cheese made from raw milk.
Kit-by-Kit Notes
New England Cheesemaking Supply Mozzarella and Ricotta
This is the classic beginner choice. The kit supplies citric acid, cheese salt, five vegetable rennet tablets, butter muslin, and a recipe booklet, and reviewers report it can make up to twenty one-pound batches. Criticisms in the roundups are that printed instructions may confuse first-timers and that it covers only two cheeses. Watching a video of the stretching technique helps.
Urban Cheesecraft
Urban Cheesecraft sells a three-cheese kit and, according to its own site, a Deluxe kit that makes several styles including burrata, goat cheese and string cheese. Reviewers describe the entry kit as a low-commitment trial with a two-year shelf life at room temperature. It includes a metal probe thermometer and cheesecloth. The limit is volume: four batches go fast once you enjoy the process.
Standing Stone Farms Ultimate
This is the variety pick, listing fourteen or more cheeses with both mesophilic and thermophilic cultures. It suits buyers who intend to move beyond fresh cheese, but they must source a thermometer, and a mold and press for hard styles.
The Big Cheese Ultimate
With ten fresh styles and forty batches, it offers breadth and a lot of practice. It includes a thermometer, molds and spices but no bacterial cultures, so cheddar and other aged styles are out of reach with this kit alone.
Fermentaholics DIY Fresh Cheese
Seven fresh cheeses, including burrata and cottage cheese, with microbial rennet tablets. It is positioned for goat, sheep and buffalo milk as well as cow milk, but you must supply a thermometer.
A Realistic First Session
Plan on roughly an hour of active work for a first batch of mozzarella or ricotta, with some waiting while the milk warms and the curd rests. Read the whole booklet before you start, measure the milk, and have the thermometer, knife, bowls and cloth laid out. Many first-timers are disappointed by a rubbery or crumbly result simply because the milk was heated too quickly or the curd was cut too early. Treat the first batch as practice, take notes on temperature and timing, and adjust on the second attempt. Most makers also offer email support or online recipes, which is worth using when something goes wrong.
Budget, Mid-Range and Premium Tiers
- Budget: Single-purpose fresh cheese kits such as the New England Cheesemaking Supply mozzarella and ricotta kit. Best value per batch.
- Mid-range: Multi-style kits with molds and a thermometer, such as The Big Cheese Ultimate.
- Premium: Deluxe or complete kits that bundle a pot, strainer, skimmer and cultures, such as the Standing Stone Farms Complete kit, or separate presses and molds for aged cheese.
Pick X If… Decision Table
| If you… | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Want homemade mozzarella this weekend | New England Cheesemaking Supply | Focused, many batches, beginner-friendly |
| Are buying a gift or testing interest | Urban Cheesecraft | Compact, thermometer and cloth included |
| Want many fresh styles with molds | The Big Cheese Ultimate | Ten styles, 40 batches |
| Want to try cheddar and feta later | Standing Stone Farms Ultimate | Includes cultures and calcium chloride |
| Use goat or sheep milk | Fermentaholics | Designed for several milk types |
Alternatives Worth Considering
- Ingredient-only packs: Fromaggio and Cultures for Health sell cultures and rennet without equipment, useful for restocking or if you already own pots and cloth.
- Cheese molds and presses: A polypropylene mold with follower (around 1.3 to 1.5 liters in the models Thomas Acres lists) and a press are the next purchase for hard cheeses.
- Yogurt and soft cheese starters: If hard cheese is not the goal, a yogurt culture can cover cream cheese and labneh with minimal gear.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use any milk?
No. Ultra-pasteurized milk generally fails to form a proper curd. Look for regular pasteurized milk with no “ultra” label, or raw milk where lawful. Check the carton before you start.
How long does homemade mozzarella keep?
Fresh cheese is best eaten within a few days, kept cold. Follow the storage advice in your kit’s booklet, and discard it if it smells sour or looks slimy.
Do I need a cheese press?
Only for hard or semi-hard cheeses such as cheddar and Gouda. Mozzarella, ricotta, paneer and similar fresh cheeses need no press.
What is the difference between vegetable and microbial rennet?
Both set milk into curd. Vegetable rennet tablets are common in beginner kits and are labeled vegetarian by the makers. Microbial rennet is produced by fermentation, and some makers use liquid forms for aged cheese recipes.
Why did my curd not set?
The most common causes are ultra-pasteurized milk, wrong temperature, or old rennet. Use a reliable thermometer, store rennet as directed, and follow the recipe timing.
Is homemade cheese cheaper than store-bought?
Sometimes, depending on milk cost, but the main reasons to make it are freshness and enjoyment. A kit pays off over multiple batches rather than a single trial.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!